Electronic Arts was as much as a victim of the Brett Favre retirement scandal which dominated headlines in sports news prior for the Mut 25 coins. Following the announcement that Favre would don his iconic Green Bay Packer uniform as the first retired player to appear in the front cover the Madden NFL game last year, EA was forced to complete a complete overhaul of the game's box art following the certain Hall of Fame quarterback revealed that he was not just delayed retirement, but was also transferring teams to join The New York Jets.

In contrast, EA's selection of an NFL all-star team to cover this year's game is as simple as throwing a touchdown over Randy Moss in single coverage. The day before, EA Sports said that Super Bowl XLIII standouts Larry Fitzgerald and Troy Polamalu will both appear on the cover of Madden NFL 25 when it is released on gamers on Xbox 360, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 5, Wii and PSP on the 14th of August. EA states the fact that Madden NFL 25 is the first time two athletes appear on the game's cover since the game's launch 21 years ago.

Larry Fitzgerald's selection to be on the Madden NFL 25 cover makes him the second player to be featured in both the professional and college editions of EA's annual gridiron sim, the prior one Shaun Alexander. As Wide receiver for the Arizona Cardinals, Fitzgerald has been picked to participate at the Pro Bowl three times, receiving MVP award during the game in 2022. Fitzgerald is also a talented wide receiver who established NFL Postseason record for the number of yards (542) as well as receptions (30) as well as touchdowns (7) last year.

A five-time Pro-Bowler as well as a the two-time Super Bowl Champion, Troy Polamalu was the captain of his team Pittsburgh Steelers' defense in the Finals of Super Bowl LIII race in the season prior to. In the course of the season the versatile safety recorded seven interceptions, and more than 73 tackles and set with the buy mut coins record for the most sacks for a safety in the course of a single contest (3).